This time of year is even scarier than the beginning of December in terms of me being an ATM. Maybe because kids can blindside you now, and by December you’re ready for them.
So innocently, my daughter said to me yesterday: We’re going to see her cousins on Thanksgiving, the first holiday of winter, as she calls it, and she knows just what gift to get them. But we should order it online now before they run out.
I was sitting at the computer entering my credit card number on the latest greatest kid electronics before I realized that we were also going to see the cousins-aunts-uncles over Christmas.
Wait just a minute. We¹re going to do Christmas/Hanukah/Kwaanza/Winter Solstice/Whatever shopping at Thanksgiving and then again in December?
How did that happen? But once she was done with her rebuttal, which seriously rivaled Jimmy Stewart¹s court speech in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, I realized that she was right, that our society has demanded double gifts, and did so nice and slowly so I didn¹t notice I was being had.
Here’s her argument: You can’t go to someone’s house and stay the long weekend and not bring cute gifts. And you know darn well when we go back to the cousins at Christmas, we’re not going empty handed.
She had me. And I’m a pragmatist. Looking at her folded arms, her smug look of victory, her iron clad logic in pink fuzzy leg warmers as she pointed back to the computer screen, I knew this was my new reality. My next challenge was to find a way to bring it within some semblance of control–after I ordered the pink electronics, of course.
So here’s the deal: I love budgets and revenge. I called my sister, knowing full well that if my little lawyer was selling me on cousin gifts, the cousins were doing the same thing. And if I was going to impose serious restrictions on my daughter, it was important that it be the same on the other end, so they weren¹t being extravagant while we were being controlled. Nothing worse than looking like the family tightwad at a holiday gathering.
That said, if you can only get your immediate family to buy in, do it anyway.
We came up with this plan:
Have your teen make a Gift Chart that includes every kid in the extended family that you’re going to see between now and New Year’s. If you¹re not going to see them, but there are other family members, they get a homemade card and a homemade food gift.
Next, put on the chart how many times you’re going to see each kid. e.g. We’re going to see cousin Olivia at Christmas but not at Thanksgiving. So she will be budgeted for one gift. We’re going to see cousin Christopher at both, so he’s budgeted for two.
Tell your teen that this year you’re doing three categories of gifts: purchased ones, handmade ones, and handmade food ones. The food ones are automatic for anyone you¹re not actually seeing, and they are one of two gifts for anyone your family is going to see twice. Food is also going to be made for stocking stuffers.
Tell your teen they can choose two people to buy gifts for, and the rest will be homemade gifts. For the purchased gifts: Have your teen go online and price what he or she considers a good Christmas gift. This can be a category, such as: kid iPod.
Have them search on an item, and then look for the best deals–may as well add the comparison shopping challenge in there. Once you find the best price, that¹s the budget. And that is it. You put the cost ceiling for each kid that is getting a purchased gift. If you have a more than one kid, it is likely that the purchased gift would be for a sibling. (Another idea to bypass even this is to get one family gift for your entire household, like a DVD player.)
Once the budget is set for the purchased, it is immovable, even if your kid decides they want to get their sibling a Wii game or a karaoke machine instead of a kid iPod (which runs $20 - $40). The reason for this is key: This is how teens get you. They rely on being fickle. As the advertisers, who are smart, don¹t forget, when they up the ante for expensive gifts, your kids are first in line to buy in.
5. An addendum rule: My daughter can spend a fortune in the “wrapping paper” category: keychains for backpacks with cute stuffed animals on them, singing cards, pocket lip gloss—all the impulse purchase stuff at the checkout counter. Have kids make these novelty items with some pom-poms, googley eyes and glue, and some clip ons you get at the crafts store.
The crafts store. Now we¹re getting to the heart and soul of this Christmas and Thanksgiving and whatever else shopping season. Craft stores are amazing fun, and kids can come up with great ideas. Honestly, they¹ll remember how much they love making things.
You make two trips. The first one is for ideas: Bring the gift chart and have the kids decide what they want to make for each person. Then go back home and see what materials you already have. You may be surprised. For instance, if you¹re making handmade stuffed animals or dolls for younger kids, old clothing can be used for the material, yarn for hair or a horse¹s or lion’s mane, old pillows for stuffing.
And you know what makes beautiful wrapping paper? Brown paper grocery bags that are painted.
After you’ve exhausted what you can make with available materials, if you still have people on your list, make a list of ideas and the materials you still need.
Then go back to the craft store, or the hardware store, or the dollar store.
In fact, comparison shop all of these for the materials you need. Include online outlets for discount craft supplies.
Keep track of everything you spend this year, if you do decide to go the homemade route. And take stock: If you have a way to compare to last year’s spending, show the kids. They¹ll be amazed. And I¹d be surprised if they don’t like what they produce far better than what they¹ve bought in the past.
I’d love to hear about craft ideas as well. And not just for the holidays: Birthdays, anniversaries, baby showers…
To keep updated on new posts, you can also subscribe to our RSS feed, on Facebook and on your Twitter page. Just add us.