We need this like a hole in the head right now.
College tuition hikes, to the tune of about 20% on average, are in place all over the country, effective immediately. For parents and students out there who have just paid the first larger bill, feeling the pinch has hit home. Families whose college kids must pay their own tuition are hit the worst, because percentage-wise it’s such an enormous part of what they could possibly be earning as waiters or bartenders.
Some states haven’t enacted the tuition increase, but plan to soon. Adding to the problem is less availability of financial aid, scholarships, and student loans.

The silver lining is that college kids I speak to and teach are potentially interested in tuition. Instead of just their usual obsession with entertainment news, they’re talking about both. Granted, hip hop star Chris Brown, who beat up his superstar singer girlfriend Rihanna, still evoke more passionate discussions, but tuition is on their radar.
Let’s take advantage of their piqued curiosity, even if it is in their inimitable partial continuous interest sort of way. (e.g. Their ears flare slightly and their eyebrows raise at the mention of tuition increase, while they continue to read their email).
Getting them to understand and grapple with tuition hikes can teach them about living with their means as cost variables change, while income stays the same or gets reduced. It can also teach them about budgets and prioritizing spending.
The biggest challenge isn’t explaining it all, it’s getting their undivided attention.
I had no luck when I just put a dollar amount on the increase. “It could be $600 extra, but it also could be $6,000!”
Flatline.
I tried upping the ante by running through the whole scare scenario: “It’s threatening the ability for some kids to continue their education, or do so without needing a job, or even extra jobs. And of course those jobs are harder to find.”
Still a flatline.
Then something occurred to me. A price tag is something they’re far too used to “coming up with”. If your teenage son wants a Wii, he’ll find a way to come up with $250, or he’ll shove it in that Christmas or birthday level of present. Your 20something daughter who “needs” that Chanel purse will do the same with that sticker shock $500 price tag (on sale now, making her even more greedy for it).
So I tried speaking in percentages. “People need to devote another 22% to this item. That’s like being told one day that your “A” grade in a class is now suddenly a “C”, unless you can solve this puzzle….”
They looked up! Ladies and gentleman, we a collective pulse!
Triggering math class and the dreaded grading system worked because they understand if they get 20% of something wrong they’re in the B- C+ range. Also, it turns out that they’re not threatened by percentages like they are with money. Grades are one thing, stuff they want to buy is another.
Kids are used to pie charts, so to move things along I made one of an entire family budget. I started with all other pie pieces being the same—particularly the amount of income coming in—just to keep it simple.
I told them that in order to increase the college pie piece by 22% we needed to reduce other pie pieces by the same amount. They could take some of the percentage from multiple pie pieces, or just one.

I went further: In order to save 22% more for college tuition, we actually need to earn an additional 30%, which will be eaten by tax.
At the mention of the tax, they were aghast. It was too much, too overwhelming. I almost lost them, until I pulled the rabbit out of the hat. There was one chance to avoid the tax: Opening a 529 college savings or tuition paying account. We’d pay no tax. That not only kept them from giving up, but they actually opened their eyes more than half mast. The game was afoot. It was like one of the “free stuff” offers on the Internet they like so much. We were back to only needing to find 22% from other pie pieces.
If you have a puzzle-loving kid in your family, it will be easy to get him or her engaged. If not, try to get them in the headspace by asking which of their friends is suffering from the recession. I overheard a 20-year-old college girl tell this to a friend: “When I went home and visited my old best friend over the weekend, we had to watch movies under a blanket. The house was freezing. They were turning the heat way down.
Be careful to create pie pieces that affect everyone, or they’ll gouge you each time. For instance, don’t make a parent clothing allowance pie piece. Make a family clothing allowance pie piece.
There’s an additional benefit to speaking in percentages. There are many parents who do not feel comfortable telling their kids what their incomes are. (We’ll do a blog on that issue, too, but feel free to chime in now. It’s a very difficult issue with a lot of tradeoffs and repercussions). If you speak in percentages and not dollar amounts, you never have to reveal your income, yet they’ll still grasp the family budget.
And if you’ve never had a family budget, this will get you started.
What are some of the stories you’re hearing from your kids about college costs in the recession?
- Anne






